Blog - Authors

HCG and Weight Loss: response to a YouTube comment


Posted on July 27th, 2009 by Matt Schoeneberger

We received a comment at YouTube in response to our recent video entry regarding HCG.  Since YouTube limits the number of characters in the comments section, we posted our response here.  The comment and our response is posted below:

Quote from 1776in2008 : “You’re wrong. The diet ALLOWS the body to release fat, but the HCG causes your body to lose the right kind of fat while protecting LBM and structural fat. Without the HCG, it would be just water and muscle weight. In those so-called ‘trials’ that you site, they only compared the weight that was lost, NOT the type of weight that was lost. Sure, someone will lose around 20 pounds on a 23 day 500 calorie diet too, but it will be water and muscle weight, NOT actual fat, like on the HCG protocol.”

First we’d like to thank you for your comment.  I’ll respond to your post one issue at a time.

“You’re wrong.”

No I’m not.

“The diet ALLOWS the body to release fat”

I believe you mean that a 500 calorie/day diet will put just about anyone in a state of negative energy balance, which will most likely cause the loss of some tissue (fat or muscle for the sake of our discussion)

“but the HCG causes your body to lose the right kind of fat while protecting LBM and structural fat”

First, your use of the term structural fat is incorrect.  This term is antiquated and is only still being used in this way by those in the HCG camp who seem to read nothing but the HCG literature, which has remained largely unchanged since the original work of Dr. Simeons in the 1950s despite many advances in the understanding of the human body, and fat in particular, since then.  You can’t ask the scientific community to prove or disprove HCG’s effects on something that doesn’t even exist.  Why not ask them to disprove the existence of unicorns and Santa Claus while we’re at it?  The term “structural fat” is now typically reserved for the use of fat in cosmetic surgery.  Please begin using the terms visceral and subcutaneous fat and others (brown adipose tissue, white adipose tissue, etc) that have been adopted by the current scientific literature (by current, I mean the last 2 or 3 decades!).

Terminology aside, HCG is not necessary, or proven, for these effects of muscle-sparing and visceral fat targeting.  Exercise has been proven to do this time and again (unlike HCG).  (Hill, Tsuzuku, Layman, Kay)

“Without the HCG, it would be just water and muscle weight.”

This statement is laughable.  It would all be water and muscle weight lost?  A person would lose 20 pounds of water and muscle?  This reveals a gross misunderstanding of basic human physiology and a stern belief in HCG folklore.  In the metabolic ward study by Hill et al., obese women who DID NOT exercise and ate an 800 calorie/day diet lost an average of 57% of their weight as fat after 5 weeks. Exercising women lost almost 75% of the weight lost as fat.  Where is the evidence to support your claim of “water and muscle” loss without HCG?

“In those so-called ‘trials’ that you site, they only compared the weight that was lost, NOT the type of weight that was lost”

Why is trial in quotations?  They are trials.  That’s what they’re called.  And, by the way, they’re the gold standard of proof of causal relationships when performed correctly.  Trials like these are what have allowed the scientific community to distinguish the bad from the good, the lies from the truth.

Yes, these trials compared the amount of total weight lost. And, actually, in addition to weight lost they compared the ability of HCG to affect the subjects’ feelings of hunger, feelings of well-being, anxiety and depression, not to mention HCG’s ability to promote fat re-distribution.  All were found to be negative.

Show me a study that proves HCG promotes positive changes in body composition better than placebo. And if you would be so kind, please also explain the mechanism behind this effect, because the ‘re-setting the hypothalamus” mumbo-jumbo has no merit in relation to your body composition argument, if it ever had any in the first place.

It seems, based on your comment, that the HCG camp is changing their tune regarding what HCG is supposed to do.  Since it’s been shot down on all the original claims (increased weight loss, reduced hunger, anxiety, depression, increased feelings of well-being, the ability to take fat away from ‘problem areas’) now you must say it changes the composition of the weight lost, that it targets the “right kind of fat while protecting LBM and structural fat”.  Well, the onus is on you to provide evidence that it works.

Dr. Simeons even stated in the forward to his original manuscript:

“Thus, when I make what reads like a factual statement, the professional reader may have to translate into: clinical experience seems to suggest that such and such an observation might be tentatively explained by such and such a working hypothesis, requiring a vast amount of further research before the hypothesis can be considered a valid theory.”

Where is this vast amount of research? If you can provide real proof that HCG does anything it’s purported to do in regards to body composition and weight loss, I’ll post a video trumpeting the benefits of HCG for body composition, Jeff and I will edit our HCG special report to reflect the new information and I’ll admit I was wrong.  Go ahead, show me proof.  Scientific proof.

These are scientific references, providing proof for claims made above.  You can get your own at a library near you:

Hill, J. O., Sparling, P. B., Shields, T. W., & Heller, P. A. (1987). Effects of exercise and food restriction on body composition and metabolic rate in obese women. The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 46(4), 622-630.

Layman, D. K., Evans, E., Baurn, J. I., Seyler, J., Erickson, D. J., & Boileau, R. A. (2005). Dietary protein and exercise have additive effects on body composition during weight loss in adult women. Journal of Nutrition, 135(8), 1903-1910.

Kay S.J., Fiatarone Singh M.A. The influence of physical activity on abdominal fat: a systematic review of the literature. Obesity Reviews. 2006;7: 183–200

Simeons ATW. Pounds and inches-a new approach to obesity. Rome, privately printed 1967.

Tsuzuku S, Kajioka T, Endo H, Abbott RD, Curb JD, Yano K. Favorable eVects of non-instrumental resistance training on fat distribution and metabolic proWles in healthy elderly people. Eur J Appl Physiol . 2007;99:549–555

Please share with friends...

19 Responses to “HCG and Weight Loss: response to a YouTube comment”

  1. Gayle Felten says:

    My brother is doing the hcg homeopathic drops :) so far he is down to the 160s (soo close to 150s) but he read somewhere (online someplace) that the homeopathic drops are safe to take ALL the way through till you lose all the weight you need (no breaks needed) because unlike our INJECTIONS that go into our blood and stay there, the drops are only temporary and so your body never quite builds an immunity. Any comments on this??? thanks!

    • Matt Schoeneberger M.S. says:

      Hi Gayle,

      Both hCG and homeopathy have been shown to be no more effective than placebo. Homeopathic hCG, by loose definition, would be a vial of water with such a small amount of hCG that even one drop of hCG in the ocean would be stronger than the homeopathic solution. Your brother’s results are solely based on his ability to stick to a very strict diet. Kudos to him!

      The portion about the immunity is absolute lies, but taking the drops will most likely not prove harmful since they are most likely just water.

      -Matt

  2. Newer technologies and advanced tools have made it possible for cosmetic surgeons to carry out the highly delicate surgical
    procedures with more confidence and mitigated risk factors.

    Calvert states, it requires a great deal of planning and preparation, as well as a
    lengthy recovery time (a three to five week hospital stay,
    with about six weeks of home rest prior to returning to work).

    With an type of plastic surgery, there will
    be a recovery process.

    Here is my page … plastic surgeon in delhi

  3. I experienced a chronic case of home sickness about
    10 seconds after I got off the bus at recruit training.
    He started with the mentally ill, the elderly, the gays, and
    other groups that were already discriminated against, and no one cared about.

    Students would read books in French (I’m thinking those meant for older children or young adults to facilitate reading ability, but if students are juniors or seniors in high school, consider using some
    of the easier French classics) and discuss the books.
    My grandfather said that his dad talked about the importance of hardening
    the hands for the cold, although most coats and jackets had pockets.
    Here are the usual mix-up of the physical activities that fitness
    boot camp have for enlistees:. -based company started franchising in 2003, Camp Bow Wow has sold more than 200 franchises in 38 states, plus one in Canada.
    Short term boot camps can motivate and encourage young children. There is also an option of day camps, which are much
    simpler as your kid would return every day after the camp.
    If we are in a current relationship and still waiting for someone from
    a past relationship to return, we are not enjoying our present relationship.
    In hockey camp, the players undergo skating drills in order to promote their agility and
    balance while being under duress.

    Look at my blog post :: Fun camps for kids boca raton

  4. But, to a trained cost accountant, it is a quick
    road map to help management analyze the business and zero in on areas for improvement.
    In a photography business in particular, here are a number
    of items that are assets to be listed for your business. Accounting software should contain common features such as
    accounts receivable, accounts payable, banking, payroll, inventory control,
    time costing, job costing, fixed assets and conversions and updates and
    more.

    my webpage; ft lauderdale CPA

  5. Body scrubs are one of the easiest homemade beauty products to make.
    Basically the foremost vital thing with skin care products is their selection. This is a review of this
    acne skincare line from this popular Tawainese skincare
    company.

    my web-site keratin treatments in nyc

  6. Arron says:

    In the last five years, the survey states, a face life, or rhytidectomy, is one of the most
    requested of all invasive procedures. I have never personally had any
    plastic surgery done but there are obvious downsides to plastic surgery
    such as downtime, pain, and possible side effects. Women are
    more likely to undergo plastic surgery but some males
    also undergo this medical procedure if they think they need to have some major changes in their body.

    my weblog … facial plastic surgeon pittsburgh (Arron)

  7. This will help to avoid streaking and will ensure
    results. Better the risk you know about than those you can’t see coming.
    There are so many different options for people to be able
    to get a natural looking tan using artificial methods.

    Here is my web-site … chloe sims wen hair skin care reviews product reviews

  8. Additionally, although a full recovery can be expected in a few days, the results of
    the RFF take a bit of time to show fully though. Delaware, Pennsylvania
    has many experienced plastic surgeons. Structural problems to the nose even after
    rhinoplasty is also a possibility, and these problems include septal perforation, sinusitis,
    and an irregularity of the nasal form.

    Feel free to surf to my blog: discount plastic hangers

  9. When using such a solution, you will be asked to talk about the events that affected you in the year, marriage, new baby, move to a new house, started
    college, changed employment status, etc. But there is an exception if
    the caregiver is your parent. Avoid hype or gimmicks and let people know
    exactly what to expect and what they are required to do in order to receive what they
    are being offered.

    Have a look at my web blog: Boca Raton CPA Firms Raton Fl

  10. Used tanning beds offer the perfect solution to getting a great tan at a really
    affordable price. You can also ask for a free advice; their representatives will be happy to help
    you. The instant will give you color as soon as you step out of the booth
    and the clear will develop over time (great for those of you who
    like to have a spray on your lunch break).

    my web page – chloe sims starship brownberry tanning new york

  11. You will probably recognise some or all of these as some as used more than others with very great
    success in carp baits:. For instance at a time when anglers where sticking rigidly to the mantra of 3 to 5 milliliters of flavour, plus 1 to 2 milliliters of intense sweetener to a pound of base mix
    or more, as measured by 4 large eggs or 6 medium eggs as a basis of measurement, I tried other approaches and reaped big rewards
    against much more experienced anglers. If you are getting ready to go
    deep-sea fishing, there are a few things you might want
    to know about sea fishing bait.

    my weblog: crock pot freezer meals for two

  12. Finally, mini face lift provide the sufferers
    an all natural experience by themselves as well as at the same
    time improve their own self esteem and confidence amounts.
    The rhinoplasty surgeons India enhance the nose by reshaping it by using components like cuboids, gristle (fibrous) and a
    couple of fashioned elements as well. First decide on what color you want your bathroom to be and add
    two shades of the same color, one lighter and one darker (or one totally different but matching color) for accents.

    Feel free to surf to my web-site featured products & reviews

  13. You might be also cost-free to eat something you would like, supplied not surprisingly which
    you stay as far away as possible from starch and sugar.
    It was a happy accident to be sure, but still an accident.
    4pt; mso-para-margin-top:0cm; mso-para-margin-right:
    0cm; mso-para-margin-bottom:10.

    Feel free to visit my web-site – hcg diet plan

  14. Exclusive apparels cost more than the ordinary clothes.
    Our outfit tells a lot about who we are or who we want to
    be. Longer neck, long neck, high collar lining, there is a Painting in the United States.

    My web page: celebrity red dresses for women

  15. Here are a few very big secrets every thinking carp angler who wants to keep ahead
    of the crowd needs to know. One big consideration is
    where you are going to store your boat and likely this will depend greatly on your budget.
    Those heated areas you make available are mighty tempting to
    them, and they know that human presence normally means an abundant,
    and readily available, source of food that they won’t need to work hard to find.

    Stop by my homepage :: deck ideas for above ground pool

  16. They want you to come to the salon on a regular basis so they tell you that
    you need to get a haircut every four to six weeks, but
    it’s just a way for them to make more money. Eventually this can cause hair thinning or patches of bald spots.
    Your hair protected the top of the head from the elements.

    My webpage laser capsulotomy definition

  17. cpap machine says:

    You can really help most of your clients by helping them use financial statements as
    a basis for making better business decisions.
    Educating these customers in how to handle their tax affairs in the future can save them many thousands of dollars.
    Avoid hype or gimmicks and let people know exactly what to expect and what they are required to do
    in order to receive what they are being offered.

    My blog … cpap machine

  18. Shavonne says:

    Fօr example, if yoսr hοme οffіcе
    іs 100 ѕquarе fеet and
    үߋսr һօmе іs ɑ tⲟtaⅼ оf 2000 sqսɑгᥱ
    fееt, then уοuг ρeгcеntaǥе іѕ 5%.
    Ⅿаny реорⅼе aге maҝіng ɑ ⅼοt ⲟf mοneү ρгоmօtіng СРΑ ⲟffегѕ, bսt aѕ ᥙѕᥙal, tһerе іѕ
    а lоt оf miѕіnfⲟгmatіοn fⅼߋating агoսnd.
    ӏ ⅾеcіⅾᥱԁ tο ᥙѕe tɦеіг
    ⲞIᏟ ѕегѵіϲe tօ ⅼߋѡеr mу taⲭ
    Ƅіⅼⅼ.

    my ԝebⅼоǥ – Fⲟгt Ꮮɑᥙԁегⅾaⅼе ᏟΡA fігms [Shavonne]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>